(Possibly) Listed in the 1639 inventory of the estate of Jan Brant (1559-1639), the original held in the archives at Gaasbeek Castle, Lennik, Belgium.
(Possibly) M. Rooses, ‘L'oeuvre de Rubens (Addenda)’, Bulletin-Rubens, Antwerp, 1896, IV, pp. 215 and 229, no. 1036bis, as ‘il est a' peine permis de douter qu'ils soient de la main de Rubens’.
(Possibly) P. Génard, ‘Het testament van Jan Brant en Clara de Moy, Rubens’ Schoonouders‘, Bulletin-Rubens, Antwerp, 1896, IV, pp. 229-230, as listed in the inventory of Jan Brant.
E. Michel, Rubens: His life, his work, and his time, London and New York, 1899, II, p. 81, as ‘now lost’.
(Possibly) M. Rooses and C. Ruelens, eds., Correspondance de Rubens et documents e´pistolaires concernant sa vie et ses oeuvres, Antwerp, 1900, III, p. 279, under ‘Commentaire’.
(Possibly) J. Denucé, De Antwerpsche 'Konstkamers', Antwerp, 1932, p. 54, quoting Jan Brant's inventory as above.
W.R. Valentiner, Sixty Paintings and Some Drawings by Peter Paul Rubens, exhibition catalogue, Detroit, 1936, no. 29, as ‘Rubens’, illustrated.
L. van Puyvelde, Les Esquisses de Rubens, Basel, 1940, pp. 17, 49, 79–80, no. 49, fig. 49, as ‘Rubens’.
M. Vaughan, ‘Old Masters at the Fair’, Parnassus, XI, no. 5, May 1939, pp. 10-11, as ‘Rubens’, illustrated.
L. van Puyvelde, The Sketches of Rubens, London, 1947, pp. 18, 51 and 81, no. 49, fig. 49, as ‘Rubens’, ‘in all probability, the portrait of Clara-Serena by Rubens mentioned in the inventory of the effects of Jean Brant’.
L. van Puyvelde, Les esquisses de Rubens, Basel, 1948, pp. 17, 49 and 79–80, no. 49, fig. 49, as ‘Rubens’.
W.R. Valentiner, ‘Rubens' Paintings in America’, The Art Quarterly, IX, Spring 1946, p. 163, no. 8, as ‘Rubens’.
J.- A. Goris and J.S. Held, Rubens in America, New York, 1947, p. 46, no. A11, pl. 7, under Appendix, as ‘not by Rubens’.
E. Haverkamp-Begemann, Olieverfschetsen van Rubens, exhibition catalogue, Rotterdam, 1953, pp. 64–5, no. 43, fig. 45, as ‘Rubens’.
O. Benesch, ‘Review of Ref. Goris and Held 1947’, Kunstchronik, VII, March 1954, p. 77, as ‘Rubens’.
J.S. Held, Rubens: Selected Drawings, London, 1959, I, p. 138, under no. 106, as ‘not by Rubens’.
M. Varshavskaya, Rubens' Paintings in the Hermitage Museum, Leningrad, 1975, p. 176, under no. 28, as ‘Studio of Rubens’, illustrated.
E. Mitsch, Die Rubenszeichnungen der Albertina, exhibition catalogue, Vienna, 1977, p. 92, under no. 38.
K. Baetjer, European Paintings in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, by artists born in or before 1865, A Summary Catalogue, New York ,1980, I, p. 161; III, p. 373, illustrated, as ‘a copy after Rubens, probably 17th century’.
W.A. Liedtke, Flemish Paintings in The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, 1984, I, pp. 231–3; II, pl. 88, as ‘a copy after Rubens, probably 17th century’.
R. Baumstark, Liechtenstein: the Princely Collections, exhibition catalogue, New York, 1985, p. 324, under no. 204, as ‘Follower of Rubens’.
H. Vlieghe, ‘Reviewed Work(s): Flemish paintings in the Metropolitan Museum of Art by Walter A. Liedtke’, Oud Holland, C, no. 3/4, 1986, pp. 202-3, as ‘a copy after Rubens’.
J.S. Held, Rubens: Selected Drawings, London, 1986, p. 133, under no. 162, as ‘not by Rubens’.
K. Baetjer, European Paintings in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, by artists born in or before 1865, A Summary Catalogue, New York, 1995, p. 282, illustrated, as ‘a copy after Rubens, probably 17th century’.
A.-M.S. Logan and M.C. Plomp, Peter Paul Rubens, exhibition catalogue, Vienna, 2004, p. 357, as ‘school of Rubens’.
A.-M.S. Logan and M.C. Plomp, Peter Paul Rubens: The Drawings, New Haven and London, 2005, pp. 244 and 246, under no. 84, as ‘school of Rubens’.
E. Crichton-Miller, 'Collector's Focus: Rubens and his Circle', Apollo, CLXXX, no. 625, November 2014, p. 98, as ‘Rubens’.
B. Grosvenor, 'As connoisseurship becomes easier, it has never been less fashionable', The Art Newspaper (online), 24 March 2015, as ‘Rubens’.
B. van Beneden, 'First Look: Rubens in Private', Apollo (online), 31 March 2015, as ‘Rubens’.
B. van Beneden, 'Some important new acquisitions for the Rubenshuis', The Rubenianum Quarterly, no. 4, 2015, p. 3, fig. 1, as ‘Rubens’.
K. Van der Stighelen, Corpus Rubenianum Ludwig Burchard: Portraits of Unidentified Sitters, XIX, forthcoming, as 'Rubens'.