M. Rooses, L'oeuvre de P.P. Rubens, Antwerp 1892, Vol. 5, p. 328, no. 351A; C. Hofstede de Groot, Die Sammlung Schubart, früher Dresden, jetzt München, Munich 1894, no. 7, reproduced; Th. von Frimmel, Zeitschrift fur Bildende Kunst, 1894, pp. 217-18, reproduced; H. Pallmann, "Aus dem Kunstbesitz des Hernn Dr. Martin Schubart", preface in sale catalog Munich 1899, p. 18 ff., no. 58; M. Rooses, Rubens, London 1904, pp. 143-4; A. Rosenberg, P.P. Rubens, Stuttgart/Leipzig 1906, no. 57, reproduced. E. Dillon, Rubens, London 1909, p. 220, plate XCI; R. Oldenbourg, P.P. Rubens, Munich/Berlin 1922, p. 452; Art in America, Vol. 31, no. 1, reproduced on the cover; W.R. Valentiner, `The smile in sculptural composition', The Art Quarterly, 1947, p. 264, figure 2; J. A. Goris and J. S. Held, Rubens in America, Antwerp 1947, p. 52, no. A63; F. Baudouin, `Een jeugdwerk van Rubens; Adam en Eva en de relatie Van Veen en Rubens', Antwerpen XI, July 1968, p. 3 ff., note 52; J. S. Held, The oil sketches of Peter Paul Rubens, Princeton 1980, Vol. 2, p. 639, no. A29; D. Freedberg, Corpus Rubenianum Ludwig Burchard, Part VII, The life of Christ after the Passion, London 1984, pp. 189-90, no. 45, reproduced, figure 115 (from an old photograph).